ADVERTISEMENT

Trump supporters with teenage daughters

Lots of gibberish there to make yourself feel better. Real question; third trimester mothers life at risk. Kill the fetus or kill the mother. Which do you choose?
Bruning car: you choose to save passenger A but don't have the time or resources to save passenger B. Did you murder passenger B?

Now to your question, it's a judgement call. Sometimes the mother makes the call. Sometimes is has be the doctor. Either way, it's the same as the burning car analogy.

Trump supporters with teenage daughters

Interesting. So any debated issue that not everyone agrees on, should be left to the states. Got it.
We are a Constitutional Republic. So yes, anything not otherwise enshrined in the US Constitution is a matter for the states. That is also a concept known as federalism. Surly this is all familiar to you? These were deliberate controls put in place to protect our unique system from the well-known failures and weaknesses of a pure democracy.

To quote Jean-Jacques Rousseau, circa 1762:
There is no other government so subject to civil wars and internal agitations as democratic or popular government, because there is none that has such a strong and continual tendency to change to another form, or that needs more vigilance and courage for its maintenance as it is. It is in a democratic system above all that the citizen should arm himself with strength and constancy, and say every day of his life what a virtuous Count Palatine said in the Polish parliament: ‘Malo periculosam, libertatem quam quietam servitutem’[*].

A population of gods could have a democratic government. A government as perfect as that is not for men.

[*] I prefer dangerous freedom over peaceful slavery
ADVERTISEMENT

Filter

ADVERTISEMENT