Him leaving after killing them to go see his mom is just as tight, especially if he did what the state said he did in that time.
⚖️ MURDAUGH MURDERS & TRIAL THREAD ⚖️
- Thread starter OldMTPTiger
- Start date
They can’t determine time of death to the minute. They can give you a range. Pushing TOD just a little each way would make it even that much more unreasonable he did it. They are trying to do that with the phones and I’m not 100% sold in that. Change that time 10 min and it changes everything.
Clemblack can spot good entertainment. I vote this as POTD.
You shouldn’t offer advice on things you know very little about, like claiming “Shot guns are not loud at all”. When you do, you leave yourself open to critique, sometimes harsh.
I’ve been reading your post and I believe you’ve swung my thoughts. I’m starting to doubt the earth is round now too. Is this what woke is?
Probably wanted to discuss the case with his attorneys in the ambulance
I sort of think motives are irrelevant. For me it's all the lies and the manipulation of people to fabricate an alibi to suit his needs. If you have nothing to hide then why all the lies??
Would you at least agree that it’s pretty obvious Alex knew their time of death?
Otherwise he had no motive to lie, and repeatedly lie, about not being with them at the kennels.
OCCUM’S RAZOR: Among competing hypotheses, the one with fewest assumptions should be selected or the simplest explanation is preferable to one that is complex. Guilty!
Both phones lock forever w/ no further activity at 8:49. TOD either 8:49 or 8:50 most likely.
Might just be oversimplification of the evidence, but:
Both phones lock at 8:49 with no further activity? Including Paul's? Didn't AM state that he replaced Paul's phone back in his pocket? Did that not register? or did it AM place it back in pocket at 8:49 at the time of death?
You haven't responded to my other posts.
but no it's not nearly as tight. Alex's own admission of being at kennels at 8:47 makes is highly questionable that he could have made it inside the house before gunshots.
He kills them at 8:49, strips, hose off near kennel and change. He had done all that before 8:53 when he picks up Maggie's phone. Wrap guns, get on golf cart and back to house. His phone moves at 9:02 and takes a shitload of steps, then he leaves at 9:06. Tight? Yes. But not tight to the point of being unreasonable or hard to fathom. It's the only plausible possibility.
You can only push it one way, and that's later. Both phones are doing stuff before 8:49. Paul's phone activity is wonderful evidence. It is damning for Alex. I know you don't like it.
- No, I may have stated that wrong. And I don't know all the correct terminology. But both phones "lock" at 8:49 with no further texting or read texts. There is "activity" after 8:49 including orientation changes and incoming calls and texts.
- I'd have to go back and see. I don't know if that registered. I'm pretty sure Alex does tell LE that he "put it back" after it had "popped out of his pocket."
- He placed it back in pocket when he discovers them at 10:06. No evidence or testimony that he messed with Paul's phone at TOD as far as I can remember.
Thanks. I was wondering about the exit. That photo shows the most likely entrance going right by the kennels, but it was possible to go to the house through another cut-in
Both phones stopped all movement except when Maggies phone started moving again with the killer.
Check out Alex. Hakeem Pinckney in this video. Wish jury could see it.
So you don't think the time stamps on the text & videos are accurate? It's not like a digital camera where after changing batteries you have to enter the date/time. A phone, like a laptop connected to the internet, are very accurate.
He steals from a quadriplegic and then exploits him by putting him in an ad to generate more potential victims. Just the worst type of human imaginable
Last edited:
That phone doesn’t determine their time of death in my opinion.
Yeah, Alex is protecting Buster against a drug gang but he was way down the list of people he contacted when he found the bodies, including Rogan, who the snapchat video was intended for. Hmmmmmmm
The coroner determined the time of death. The phones merely support it.
Why are defense attorneys generally so much better than prosecutors?
I’m catching up listening to Waters interview Alex and Waters comes across as such a little douche. Alex actually seems pretty likeable and charismatic.
Are prosecutors often aspiring to be defense attorneys one day or not necessarily? Just seems like generally defense attorneys are better at their jobs and more appealing to the jury.
I’m catching up listening to Waters interview Alex and Waters comes across as such a little douche. Alex actually seems pretty likeable and charismatic.
Are prosecutors often aspiring to be defense attorneys one day or not necessarily? Just seems like generally defense attorneys are better at their jobs and more appealing to the jury.
It fascinates me that people get hung up on motive, or the fact they can’t personally imagine someone killing family members. Is this the first time in recorded history that a man shot his wife and child?
Who knows what AM was thinking at the time, whether he planned it or something happened to set him off, but he’s boxed in on the timeline and his lies - he’s guilty.
Who knows what AM was thinking at the time, whether he planned it or something happened to set him off, but he’s boxed in on the timeline and his lies - he’s guilty.
