ADVERTISEMENT

Clemson and NewSpring

Originally posted by SWUtigers:


Also, what is it about this "church" that makes people get so defensive? I have close friends that work and/or attend services and they are borderline militant about this place.
Having witnessed PN's teachings a couple of times, that behavior is born and fostered by the way he speaks about his skeptics/critics in his sermons. His tone and attitude is one of butthurt and mockery when anyone challenges why he/New Spring do things the way they do. Reference this uncensored version of him doing just that here. While I do believe his core intentions are good, there's no denying his clear narcissism and narrow focus on numbers.
 
Certainly don't disagree with the point of the empty tomb, but did think of Galatians 6:14. God forbid that I should boast except in the cross of Christ...
 
Originally posted by tiger-gal2:
Originally posted by OrangeForever:


Originally posted by SWUtigers:
Thank you for the summation, elvis and miller.

I do have one more question, I hear there are no crosses in the church. If so, what's their justification for this?

Posted from Rivals Mobile
Total Transparency: I was a non-believer, pretty much a horrible person, before I started going to NewSpring in 00/01ish....probably late 01. New Spring was tiny, less than 200 people total meeting at Anderson College (lol at calling that place a university).

I don't know about crosses, but as someone who is not 'religious' per se I do not understand why so many Christians utilize the cross as a symbol -- would not the empty tomb be a little more significant for a believer? The cross was a preferred means of execution -- as Christians we have hope because of the empty tomb.

I liked a lot about New Spring and as a complete train wreck walking in the environment was perfect for me, but as I grew older wanted a little more expository preaching style but also with a similar emphasis on the gospel, applications, pragmatics and sanctification.

I would be honest if Perry's 'rock star' persona wasn't troubling to me....
Agree with this. Most Newspring folks I come in contact with have PN so high on a pedestal that only God could be his equal. "I love my church" and " I love my pastor" are heard ten times more than "I love my Lord and Saviour" Thankful for the souls he has reached but pretty skeptical of the hero worship culture that seems to exist there.
I understand what you are saying about the "hero worship" culture. However, most of the time it's not the leaders who create this, but it's immature followers who do. This has always been a problem. Paul wrote 1 Corinthians to address "hero worship" in that congregation and he was one of the heroes the people there were worshipping. In church history we have "camps" and theological positions that are stated around the names of "Christian heroes" : Calvinist, Lutheran, Wesleyan, Arminian, Zwingliest. This is not a Newspring problem it is a people problem that has been a thorn in the side of the Body of Christ since the first century church. It is also a mark of spiritual immaturity. Some leaders do promote it, most don't. Also, just because someone says they love their pastor and want to honor the leaders God has given to them to add value to their lives, there is nothing wrong with that. When we value leadership, we are valuing what God values. However, it can go overboard. Just my 2 cents.
 
Originally posted by CU Alumnus:

Originally posted by jmh9713:

"On June 13, Ben Milstead mailed a signed resignation letter in my
name to the provost at Anderson University, where I am a tenured
associate professor of communication. On June 16, the provost emailed me
to communicate his regret at my resignation. I informed him that it was
a hoax and, thankfully, retained my job.


Milstead later explained that he had discussed the plan to send the
letter with Maxwell, and they had wanted it to draw the university's
attention to my blog, with the goal of having them censor it or shut it
down.


It didn't work that way, and their assumption demonstrated a poor
understanding of the place of debate within a Christian liberal arts
institution. University administrators have never talked to me about my
blog, either to praise it or condemn it. So long as I'm not speaking for
the university?and I'm not?, our robust academic community encourages
thinking and debate on a wide range of important issues."


Correct me if I am wrong, but doesn't Ben Milstead work for WCCP?
Can you explain this a little? Who's name was the resignation letter sent in?
To the first question, yes, Ben Milstead is the producer of Philpott's show.

To the second question, Milstead apparently sent a signed resignation letter into Anderson University pretending to be written and signed by professor James Duncan, the blogger who was critical of Noble/NewSpring.

If you continue reading the story, it sounds like Milstead was repentant of his actions. Noble/NewSpring have basically absolved themselves of the whole situation acting like they never knew that the blogger was being harassed.
 
Fair enough Mac Tiger. I understand your point and basically agree with it. I think you and a previous poster hit the nail on the head when you talked about immature followers and there being a low ceiling of growth there at New Spring scripturally speaking. For the lives reached there I am glad and trust that good things are happening. I have just seen too many mega star preachers brought down by their ego, love of money and power or other vices. Maybe thats the source of my skepticism, especially if you read some of Perry's critics experiences
 
Originally posted by mccadoyle:

Originally posted by CU Alumnus:

Originally posted by jmh9713:

"On June 13, Ben Milstead mailed a signed resignation letter in my
name to the provost at Anderson University, where I am a tenured
associate professor of communication. On June 16, the provost emailed me
to communicate his regret at my resignation. I informed him that it was
a hoax and, thankfully, retained my job.


Milstead later explained that he had discussed the plan to send the
letter with Maxwell, and they had wanted it to draw the university's
attention to my blog, with the goal of having them censor it or shut it
down.


It didn't work that way, and their assumption demonstrated a poor
understanding of the place of debate within a Christian liberal arts
institution. University administrators have never talked to me about my
blog, either to praise it or condemn it. So long as I'm not speaking for
the university?and I'm not?, our robust academic community encourages
thinking and debate on a wide range of important issues."


Correct me if I am wrong, but doesn't Ben Milstead work for WCCP?
Can you explain this a little? Who's name was the resignation letter sent in?
To the first question, yes, Ben Milstead is the producer of Philpott's show.

To the second question, Milstead apparently sent a signed resignation letter into Anderson University pretending to be written and signed by professor James Duncan, the blogger who was critical of Noble/NewSpring.

If you continue reading the story, it sounds like Milstead was repentant of his actions. Noble/NewSpring have basically absolved themselves of the whole situation acting like they never knew that the blogger was being harassed.
If true........Ben Milstead is a complete loser dbag
 
How on God's green earth do you get addicted to porn? Is Perry really addicted?
 
Originally posted by Charleston3383:

I attended and volunteered at Newspring for 2 years at Clemson. It is a good church. They are very evangelical. However, they seek to be controversial with sound bites from sermons, sermon titles, songs played in worsip, etc. Then members become very defensive and offended when that controversy is addressed and debated.

My other observation is that Perry will cycle through the same topics: finance, marriage, creativity, evangelism, etc. Then use scripture to support his message. He is not seminary trained (open for debate but important to me as understanding cultural and original language context is huge). He also is not an expository preacher who focuses on a passage of scripture and then comes up with a thesis.

The culture of mega churches is cause for some alarm. When Perry or band members would walk into the volunteer room, they were treated as rock stars with many just looking to be assosciated wtih Lee or Perry to be seen as cool, etc. Egos are large in that church. A good example is Perry does not do hospital visits, marriages, funerals, etc. I know the external reasoning is that he can't do it for everyone and doesn't want to have it outwardly appear as favoritism. But, larger churches like Seacoast, East Cooper, First Presbyterian, etc. don't have policy like that.

Oh, and this is a 3 page minimum thread.


Sorta...I am a Newspring owner. If anyone ever wants to debate anything that Newspring does, I'm all for it, and many times, I'd agree with the other person's stance. I don't agree with everything Newspring does. However, calling the criticism that Newspring receives "debate" is a stretch. That'd be like calling some of the flame posts on TI debates. They're not debates, they're attacks. Yes, if we were better Christians we wouldn't let that bother us, but we're not perfect, so we stick up for ourselves, our Pastor, and our Church.

I don't know Perry but I get the sense that his "rockstar status" is unwanted rather than desired, and more of a curse than a blessing.
 
Originally posted by Trading Tiger:

Originally posted by Charleston3383:

I attended and volunteered at Newspring for 2 years at Clemson. It is a good church. They are very evangelical. However, they seek to be controversial with sound bites from sermons, sermon titles, songs played in worsip, etc. Then members become very defensive and offended when that controversy is addressed and debated.

My other observation is that Perry will cycle through the same topics: finance, marriage, creativity, evangelism, etc. Then use scripture to support his message. He is not seminary trained (open for debate but important to me as understanding cultural and original language context is huge). He also is not an expository preacher who focuses on a passage of scripture and then comes up with a thesis.

The culture of mega churches is cause for some alarm. When Perry or band members would walk into the volunteer room, they were treated as rock stars with many just looking to be assosciated wtih Lee or Perry to be seen as cool, etc. Egos are large in that church. A good example is Perry does not do hospital visits, marriages, funerals, etc. I know the external reasoning is that he can't do it for everyone and doesn't want to have it outwardly appear as favoritism. But, larger churches like Seacoast, East Cooper, First Presbyterian, etc. don't have policy like that.

Oh, and this is a 3 page minimum thread.


Sorta...I am a Newspring owner. If anyone ever wants to debate anything that Newspring does, I'm all for it, and many times, I'd agree with the other person's stance. I don't agree with everything Newspring does. However, calling the criticism that Newspring receives "debate" is a stretch. That'd be like calling some of the flame posts on TI debates. They're not debates, they're attacks. Yes, if we were better Christians we wouldn't let that bother us, but we're not perfect, so we stick up for ourselves, our Pastor, and our Church.

I don't know Perry but I get the sense that his "rockstar status" is unwanted rather than desired, and more of a curse than a blessing.
I have never been to a newspring service or know Perry Noble, but to say he does not want his "rockstar status" is a bit of a reach. Guy puts himself in the spotlight every single chance he gets.

What exactly is a "Newspring Owner" Do you franchise out Newsprings like you would a Subway or McDonalds?
 
Originally posted by SWUtigers:
Although I thought the atheist/agnostic article about Clemson is nothing to see, I can't help but wonder how influential NewSpring is to the Program. Anyone care to elaborate?

Also, what is it about this "church" that makes people get so defensive? I have close friends that work and/or attend services and they are borderline militant about this place. This blog, in particular, makes me wonder about the "culture" being created in mega churches.

Perhaps I just don't understand because I've never set foot in there but I wonder what some here have to say.
I'm an owner (what we call members) and LOVE my church. Our church, or any church for that matter, is not for everyone. But I LOVE my chuch, and we are reaching thousands across this state for Jesus. I'm proud of that, and I'm proud of ALL churches doing that. EDIT: For another poster above, we say "I love my church" because (1) we love Jesus and the church is the bride of Christ, and (2) we truly do love our church. I love Jesus Christ, my lord and savior, more than anything in this world and in eternity, and He is the reason that I live and am blessed with each day.




This post was edited on 4/16 3:54 PM by Mr. Clemson
 
Originally posted by Mr. Clemson:
Originally posted by SWUtigers:
Although I thought the atheist/agnostic article about Clemson is nothing to see, I can't help but wonder how influential NewSpring is to the Program. Anyone care to elaborate?

Also, what is it about this "church" that makes people get so defensive? I have close friends that work and/or attend services and they are borderline militant about this place. This blog, in particular, makes me wonder about the "culture" being created in mega churches.

Perhaps I just don't understand because I've never set foot in there but I wonder what some here have to say.
I'm an owner (what we call members) and LOVE my church. Our church, or any church for that matter, is not for everyone. But I LOVE my chuch, and we are reaching thousands across this state for Jesus. I'm proud of that, and I'm proud of ALL churches doing that.
Ok....now I am really confused. Exactly how are you an owner of Newspring?
 
My question is, with Newsprings popping up all over the place is it about to become it's own denomination of Protestantism? Or can Newspring folk even be considered Protestants?

I attend an Episcopal Church so that makes me Episcopalian. Are folks that attend Noble's churches Newspringian?

I'm just trying to understand here. I am skeptical of any church that makes it's lead pastor a multi millionaire and that has an almost cult following by it's masses. I'm not saying it's a bad place to worship and I'm sure it brings non believers to Christ all the time, but color me skeptical about what's going on in the upper levels of this church behind the scenes.

And just for the record I'm not making fun of Christianity as a whole. I'm very much a Christian.
This post was edited on 4/16 3:52 PM by acwill07
 
Originally posted by jmh9713:

Originally posted by Trading Tiger:


Originally posted by Charleston3383:

I attended and volunteered at Newspring for 2 years at Clemson. It is a good church. They are very evangelical. However, they seek to be controversial with sound bites from sermons, sermon titles, songs played in worsip, etc. Then members become very defensive and offended when that controversy is addressed and debated.

My other observation is that Perry will cycle through the same topics: finance, marriage, creativity, evangelism, etc. Then use scripture to support his message. He is not seminary trained (open for debate but important to me as understanding cultural and original language context is huge). He also is not an expository preacher who focuses on a passage of scripture and then comes up with a thesis.

The culture of mega churches is cause for some alarm. When Perry or band members would walk into the volunteer room, they were treated as rock stars with many just looking to be assosciated wtih Lee or Perry to be seen as cool, etc. Egos are large in that church. A good example is Perry does not do hospital visits, marriages, funerals, etc. I know the external reasoning is that he can't do it for everyone and doesn't want to have it outwardly appear as favoritism. But, larger churches like Seacoast, East Cooper, First Presbyterian, etc. don't have policy like that.

Oh, and this is a 3 page minimum thread.


Sorta...I am a Newspring owner. If anyone ever wants to debate anything that Newspring does, I'm all for it, and many times, I'd agree with the other person's stance. I don't agree with everything Newspring does. However, calling the criticism that Newspring receives "debate" is a stretch. That'd be like calling some of the flame posts on TI debates. They're not debates, they're attacks. Yes, if we were better Christians we wouldn't let that bother us, but we're not perfect, so we stick up for ourselves, our Pastor, and our Church.

I don't know Perry but I get the sense that his "rockstar status" is unwanted rather than desired, and more of a curse than a blessing.
I have never been to a newspring service or know Perry Noble, but to say he does not want his "rockstar status" is a bit of a reach. Guy puts himself in the spotlight every single chance he gets.

What exactly is a "Newspring Owner" Do you franchise out Newsprings like you would a Subway or McDonalds?
We use the term "owner" rather than "member." The reason we do so is because Christ called all of us to play an active role in the church and actively pursue others with the gospel. We take "ownership" in our church by being active and involved members, so that's why we use the term owner rather than member. That's all really.
 
Originally posted by acwill07:
My question is, with Newsprings popping up all over the place is it about to become it's own denomination of Protestantism? Or can Newspring folk even be considered Protestants?

I attend an Episcopal Church so that makes me Episcopalian. Are folks that attend Noble's churches Newspringian?

I'm just trying to understand here. I am skeptical of any church that makes it's lead pastor a multi millionaire and that has an almost cult following by it's masses. I'm not saying it's a bad place to worship and I'm sure it brings non believers to Christ all the time, but color me skeptical about what's going on in the upper levels of this church behind the scenes.

And just for the record I'm not making fun of Christianity as a whole. I'm very much a Christian.
This post was edited on 4/16 3:52 PM by acwill07
New age Benny Hen

images
 
Originally posted by Mr. Clemson:
Originally posted by jmh9713:

Originally posted by Trading Tiger:


Originally posted by Charleston3383:

I attended and volunteered at Newspring for 2 years at Clemson. It is a good church. They are very evangelical. However, they seek to be controversial with sound bites from sermons, sermon titles, songs played in worsip, etc. Then members become very defensive and offended when that controversy is addressed and debated.

My other observation is that Perry will cycle through the same topics: finance, marriage, creativity, evangelism, etc. Then use scripture to support his message. He is not seminary trained (open for debate but important to me as understanding cultural and original language context is huge). He also is not an expository preacher who focuses on a passage of scripture and then comes up with a thesis.

The culture of mega churches is cause for some alarm. When Perry or band members would walk into the volunteer room, they were treated as rock stars with many just looking to be assosciated wtih Lee or Perry to be seen as cool, etc. Egos are large in that church. A good example is Perry does not do hospital visits, marriages, funerals, etc. I know the external reasoning is that he can't do it for everyone and doesn't want to have it outwardly appear as favoritism. But, larger churches like Seacoast, East Cooper, First Presbyterian, etc. don't have policy like that.

Oh, and this is a 3 page minimum thread.


Sorta...I am a Newspring owner. If anyone ever wants to debate anything that Newspring does, I'm all for it, and many times, I'd agree with the other person's stance. I don't agree with everything Newspring does. However, calling the criticism that Newspring receives "debate" is a stretch. That'd be like calling some of the flame posts on TI debates. They're not debates, they're attacks. Yes, if we were better Christians we wouldn't let that bother us, but we're not perfect, so we stick up for ourselves, our Pastor, and our Church.

I don't know Perry but I get the sense that his "rockstar status" is unwanted rather than desired, and more of a curse than a blessing.
I have never been to a newspring service or know Perry Noble, but to say he does not want his "rockstar status" is a bit of a reach. Guy puts himself in the spotlight every single chance he gets.

What exactly is a "Newspring Owner" Do you franchise out Newsprings like you would a Subway or McDonalds?
We use the term "owner" rather than "member." The reason we do so is because Christ called all of us to play an active role in the church and actively pursue others with the gospel. We take "ownership" in our church by being active and involved members, so that's why we use the term owner rather than member. That's all really.
Man this is starting to sound pyramid schemish. I don't get this concept. You are a member of a church. A member of anything is supposed to be active within that group. I thought that was understood.

I guess im being too critical, but what exactly do you do as an owner that normal church members to do not do. I guess why the distinction?
 
Originally posted by jmh9713:
Originally posted by acwill07:
My question is, with Newsprings popping up all over the place is it about to become it's own denomination of Protestantism? Or can Newspring folk even be considered Protestants?

I attend an Episcopal Church so that makes me Episcopalian. Are folks that attend Noble's churches Newspringian?

I'm just trying to understand here. I am skeptical of any church that makes it's lead pastor a multi millionaire and that has an almost cult following by it's masses. I'm not saying it's a bad place to worship and I'm sure it brings non believers to Christ all the time, but color me skeptical about what's going on in the upper levels of this church behind the scenes.

And just for the record I'm not making fun of Christianity as a whole. I'm very much a Christian.
This post was edited on 4/16 3:52 PM by acwill07
New age Benny Hen

images
Congratulations on the worst post ITT
 
Originally posted by acwill07:
My question is, with Newsprings popping up all over the place is it about to become it's own denomination of Protestantism? Or can Newspring folk even be considered Protestants?

I attend an Episcopal Church so that makes me Episcopalian. Are folks that attend Noble's churches Newspringian?

I'm just trying to understand here. I am skeptical of any church that makes it's lead pastor a multi millionaire and that has an almost cult following by it's masses. I'm not saying it's a bad place to worship and I'm sure it brings non believers to Christ all the time, but color me skeptical about what's going on in the upper levels of this church behind the scenes.

And just for the record I'm not making fun of Christianity as a whole. I'm very much a Christian.

This post was edited on 4/16 3:52 PM by acwill07
It doesn't matter to me what denomination you call us. Our goal is to reach as many people across this state, country and world for Jesus Christ. Seeing hearts changed and people saved in the name of Jesus is the most important thing, and that's what our church is all about. We will do anything biblically correct, short of sin, to reach those far away from God. Eevery number has a name, every name has a story, and every story matters to God. And because of that, we are always going to celebrate numbers/salvations at our church and reach as many people as possible. Anyone is welcomed at our church no matter what you've done in your past or where you are right now. As we say, "it's okay to not be okay, but it's not okay to stay that way."

I am a volunteer and pretty involved with the church, and I can tell you that Perry is not a multi-millionaire. Regardless, is it not okay for a pastor to make a good living? I believe that, like in a for profit corporation or public institution like Clemson, you should reward those leading your company, school, etc. to great things. Perry started our church years ago in Anderson, and he is a big (not the only) reason why so many people have been saved over the years. His job, like many of ours, is very stressful at times, and he should be rewarded for that.
 
Originally posted by jmh9713:


Originally posted by Mr. Clemson:


Originally posted by jmh9713:



Originally posted by Trading Tiger:




Originally posted by Charleston3383:

I attended and volunteered at Newspring for 2 years at Clemson. It is a good church. They are very evangelical. However, they seek to be controversial with sound bites from sermons, sermon titles, songs played in worsip, etc. Then members become very defensive and offended when that controversy is addressed and debated.

My other observation is that Perry will cycle through the same topics: finance, marriage, creativity, evangelism, etc. Then use scripture to support his message. He is not seminary trained (open for debate but important to me as understanding cultural and original language context is huge). He also is not an expository preacher who focuses on a passage of scripture and then comes up with a thesis.

The culture of mega churches is cause for some alarm. When Perry or band members would walk into the volunteer room, they were treated as rock stars with many just looking to be assosciated wtih Lee or Perry to be seen as cool, etc. Egos are large in that church. A good example is Perry does not do hospital visits, marriages, funerals, etc. I know the external reasoning is that he can't do it for everyone and doesn't want to have it outwardly appear as favoritism. But, larger churches like Seacoast, East Cooper, First Presbyterian, etc. don't have policy like that.

Oh, and this is a 3 page minimum thread.


Sorta...I am a Newspring owner. If anyone ever wants to debate anything that Newspring does, I'm all for it, and many times, I'd agree with the other person's stance. I don't agree with everything Newspring does. However, calling the criticism that Newspring receives "debate" is a stretch. That'd be like calling some of the flame posts on TI debates. They're not debates, they're attacks. Yes, if we were better Christians we wouldn't let that bother us, but we're not perfect, so we stick up for ourselves, our Pastor, and our Church.

I don't know Perry but I get the sense that his "rockstar status" is unwanted rather than desired, and more of a curse than a blessing.
I have never been to a newspring service or know Perry Noble, but to say he does not want his "rockstar status" is a bit of a reach. Guy puts himself in the spotlight every single chance he gets.

What exactly is a "Newspring Owner" Do you franchise out Newsprings like you would a Subway or McDonalds?
We use the term "owner" rather than "member." The reason we do so is because Christ called all of us to play an active role in the church and actively pursue others with the gospel. We take "ownership" in our church by being active and involved members, so that's why we use the term owner rather than member. That's all really.




Man this is starting to sound pyramid schemish. I don't get this concept. You are a member of a church. A member of anything is supposed to be active within that group. I thought that was understood.

I guess im being too critical, but what exactly do you do as an owner that normal church members to do not do. I guess why the distinction?
I agree and we understand that everyone should be involved in a local church (and it doesn't have to be our church). It's just a different term that we chose to use. It's not a big deal or anything different from a member of another church. We just encourage people to get involved with the local church, because many people just go to church on Sunday morning and that's not solely what Jesus called us to do. And we believe (as Jesus said) that you can't do life alone.
This post was edited on 4/16 4:11 PM by Mr. Clemson
 
Originally posted by jmh9713:

Originally posted by Mr. Clemson:

Originally posted by jmh9713:


Originally posted by Trading Tiger:



Originally posted by Charleston3383:

I attended and volunteered at Newspring for 2 years at Clemson. It is a good church. They are very evangelical. However, they seek to be controversial with sound bites from sermons, sermon titles, songs played in worsip, etc. Then members become very defensive and offended when that controversy is addressed and debated.

My other observation is that Perry will cycle through the same topics: finance, marriage, creativity, evangelism, etc. Then use scripture to support his message. He is not seminary trained (open for debate but important to me as understanding cultural and original language context is huge). He also is not an expository preacher who focuses on a passage of scripture and then comes up with a thesis.

The culture of mega churches is cause for some alarm. When Perry or band members would walk into the volunteer room, they were treated as rock stars with many just looking to be assosciated wtih Lee or Perry to be seen as cool, etc. Egos are large in that church. A good example is Perry does not do hospital visits, marriages, funerals, etc. I know the external reasoning is that he can't do it for everyone and doesn't want to have it outwardly appear as favoritism. But, larger churches like Seacoast, East Cooper, First Presbyterian, etc. don't have policy like that.

Oh, and this is a 3 page minimum thread.


Sorta...I am a Newspring owner. If anyone ever wants to debate anything that Newspring does, I'm all for it, and many times, I'd agree with the other person's stance. I don't agree with everything Newspring does. However, calling the criticism that Newspring receives "debate" is a stretch. That'd be like calling some of the flame posts on TI debates. They're not debates, they're attacks. Yes, if we were better Christians we wouldn't let that bother us, but we're not perfect, so we stick up for ourselves, our Pastor, and our Church.

I don't know Perry but I get the sense that his "rockstar status" is unwanted rather than desired, and more of a curse than a blessing.
I have never been to a newspring service or know Perry Noble, but to say he does not want his "rockstar status" is a bit of a reach. Guy puts himself in the spotlight every single chance he gets.

What exactly is a "Newspring Owner" Do you franchise out Newsprings like you would a Subway or McDonalds?
We use the term "owner" rather than "member." The reason we do so is because Christ called all of us to play an active role in the church and actively pursue others with the gospel. We take "ownership" in our church by being active and involved members, so that's why we use the term owner rather than member. That's all really.


Man this is starting to sound pyramid schemish. I don't get this concept. You are a member of a church. A member of anything is supposed to be active within that group. I thought that was understood.

I guess im being too critical, but what exactly do you do as an owner that normal church members to do not do. I guess why the distinction?
Your first post is a prime example of the difference between debating and attacking as I pointed out. You've never been to Newspring and you don't know Perry, but you know that he puts himself in the spotlight. Clearly you don't understand the difference between wanting to be in the spotlight and having the spotlight put on you.

Members have rights, owners have responsibilities. That's why Newspring doesn't have "members", we have owners. It's semantics, but it also drives a good point. I know lots of "active members" of other churches who do nothing but go to church every now and again. When you take owernship in something, it means a little bit more to you and you want to be more involved.
 
Originally posted by acwill07:
My question is, with Newsprings popping up all over the place is it about to become it's own denomination of Protestantism? Or can Newspring folk even be considered Protestants?

I attend an Episcopal Church so that makes me Episcopalian. Are folks that attend Noble's churches Newspringian?

I'm just trying to understand here. I am skeptical of any church that makes it's lead pastor a multi millionaire and that has an almost cult following by it's masses. I'm not saying it's a bad place to worship and I'm sure it brings non believers to Christ all the time, but color me skeptical about what's going on in the upper levels of this church behind the scenes.

And just for the record I'm not making fun of Christianity as a whole. I'm very much a Christian.

This post was edited on 4/16 3:52 PM by acwill07
They identify as a community church. They started at Anderson and that is a baptist school. They baptise (sp?), which is unique to Baptists and maybe methodists. The full immersion thing, ya know?

Question, has anyone ever been inside of seacoast in Mt Pleasant? How does it compare to the new campus of Newspring? Seems almost like a village square type set-up. Coffee House, bookstore, etc.
 
Originally posted by haymond1977:
You guys werent searching the web with one hand back then? You could break my sheets in half 7 years ago.

I dont mind picking at myself. Im sure some on here still beat it like it owes you money.
Sounds like you don't mind doing a lot to yourself.
 
Originally posted by Charleston3383:
Originally posted by acwill07:
My question is, with Newsprings popping up all over the place is it about to become it's own denomination of Protestantism? Or can Newspring folk even be considered Protestants?

I attend an Episcopal Church so that makes me Episcopalian. Are folks that attend Noble's churches Newspringian?

I'm just trying to understand here. I am skeptical of any church that makes it's lead pastor a multi millionaire and that has an almost cult following by it's masses. I'm not saying it's a bad place to worship and I'm sure it brings non believers to Christ all the time, but color me skeptical about what's going on in the upper levels of this church behind the scenes.

And just for the record I'm not making fun of Christianity as a whole. I'm very much a Christian.

This post was edited on 4/16 3:52 PM by acwill07
They identify as a community church. They started at Anderson and that is a baptist school. They baptise (sp?), which is unique to Baptists and maybe methodists. The full immersion thing, ya know?

Question, has anyone ever been inside of seacoast in Mt Pleasant? How does it compare to the new campus of Newspring? Seems almost like a village square type set-up. Coffee House, bookstore, etc.
Baptism is not unique to Baptists and Methodists. Lutherans, Catholics, and several other denominations do it as well. I think they all do.

The method (sprinkle vs dunking) differs though. I think sprinkling is done more for convenience though.
 
Noble is nothing more than David Koresh 2.0. He's a false prophet and his "followers" are worshipping a false idol.
 
Originally posted by jmh9713:
Originally posted by Trading Tiger:

Originally posted by Charleston3383:

I attended and volunteered at Newspring for 2 years at Clemson. It is a good church. They are very evangelical. However, they seek to be controversial with sound bites from sermons, sermon titles, songs played in worsip, etc. Then members become very defensive and offended when that controversy is addressed and debated.

My other observation is that Perry will cycle through the same topics: finance, marriage, creativity, evangelism, etc. Then use scripture to support his message. He is not seminary trained (open for debate but important to me as understanding cultural and original language context is huge). He also is not an expository preacher who focuses on a passage of scripture and then comes up with a thesis.

The culture of mega churches is cause for some alarm. When Perry or band members would walk into the volunteer room, they were treated as rock stars with many just looking to be assosciated wtih Lee or Perry to be seen as cool, etc. Egos are large in that church. A good example is Perry does not do hospital visits, marriages, funerals, etc. I know the external reasoning is that he can't do it for everyone and doesn't want to have it outwardly appear as favoritism. But, larger churches like Seacoast, East Cooper, First Presbyterian, etc. don't have policy like that.

Oh, and this is a 3 page minimum thread.


Sorta...I am a Newspring owner. If anyone ever wants to debate anything that Newspring does, I'm all for it, and many times, I'd agree with the other person's stance. I don't agree with everything Newspring does. However, calling the criticism that Newspring receives "debate" is a stretch. That'd be like calling some of the flame posts on TI debates. They're not debates, they're attacks. Yes, if we were better Christians we wouldn't let that bother us, but we're not perfect, so we stick up for ourselves, our Pastor, and our Church.

I don't know Perry but I get the sense that his "rockstar status" is unwanted rather than desired, and more of a curse than a blessing.
I have never been to a newspring service or know Perry Noble, but to say he does not want his "rockstar status" is a bit of a reach. Guy puts himself in the spotlight every single chance he gets.

What exactly is a "Newspring Owner" Do you franchise out Newsprings like you would a Subway or McDonalds?
So, basically you don't know what you are talking about...
 
Originally posted by d-tiger45:
Noble is nothing more than David Koresh 2.0. He's a false prophet and his "followers" are worshipping a false idol.
Ok. Please explain how you know this.
 
I can understand the skepticism and that is one of the reasons it took me a while to join NewSpring and become an active owner. I was a huge skeptic of these mega churches as a result of all the Pastors you would hear about on TV News in the 80/90's and how corrupt they were at stealing your money. However, I joined in 2006 and really started to like it and learning more and more about the word of God.

First and foremost, the Church has the best program I have ever witnessed for children, it's called KidSpring. I have a 4 yr old daughter and 6 yr old son. They can't wait to go to Church on Sunday's because the Church has made it fun to learn about Jesus and the word of God. I can't say the same thing for me growing up in an Episcopal church as a child. It was boring as paint back then(70's, early 80's) and I despised going.

If people attending NewSpring go to see Perry Noble alone as an Worship idol, they must leave disappointed half the time. There are several other Pastors who regularly speak at NewSpring now and are very good. One of my favorites is Clayton King out of the Charlotte area. My point is NewSpring isn't about Perry Noble, he's not even there every Sunday and likely preaches about 2/3 of the Services now if I had to guess.

One of the ways, myself in particular have expanded my learnings about Christ and the teachings within the Bible is what is called "Home Groups" concept now (basically Adult Sunday School concept). It has certainly expanded my limited ceiling and understanding of what I learn on top of the Sunday services.

Sorry for the long post TigerGal, just wanted to throw my .02c in the ring. NewSpring isn't for everyone, but I believe in what they are doing and see it every Sunday. They put a TON of money back in the community throughout this State alone.


Originally posted by tiger-gal2:
Fair enough Mac Tiger. I understand your point and basically agree with it. I think you and a previous poster hit the nail on the head when you talked about immature followers and there being a low ceiling of growth there at New Spring scripturally speaking. For the lives reached there I am glad and trust that good things are happening. I have just seen too many mega star preachers brought down by their ego, love of money and power or other vices. Maybe thats the source of my skepticism, especially if you read some of Perry's critics experiences
 
That's what I read on twitter. Everyone knows twitter don't tell no lies.
 
I have been to NS once in Florence. However, I have watched several sermons online.

It's not my preferred kind of church. I am Presbyterian and we have two services, traditional and non. But, from what I have gathered thus far, I have no problem with the NS model. There is no doubt they are reaching A LOT of people and converting A LOT of people.

My kids, on the other hand, 8, 7 & 4, love to go to NS. My wife will take them often after our regular church and sometimes instead of.

The key thing to NS is they are attracting mostly young people who very well not be at church, and more importantly, who may not have been saved had it not been for NS. I think that's great.

If you have problems with NS, that is certainly your prerogative. Nothing wrong with that. What makes me laugh is the people who bust on PN and NS who have absolutely no idea WTF they are talking about. Believers and non-believers alike take plenty of shots at NS without having ever set foot in the place or without ever listening to PN's sermons. That is the height of stupidity.
 
Originally posted by d-tiger45:
That's what I read on twitter. Everyone knows twitter don't tell no lies.
Well, I commend you on admitting you didn't know what you were talking about or a poor attempt at humor. Whichever it was.
 
I'll buy you a beer next time I'm at the Toad if you Newspringers are allowed to imbibe demon malt
 
Originally posted by d-tiger45:
I'll buy you a beer next time I'm at the Toad if you Newspringers are allowed to imbibe demon malt
Not a Newspringer but I'll take the beer.
 
Just curious for the newspringers... does NS encourage its members to do business with other members? Say someone is looking for a financial adviser, does NS do any promoting (direct or indirect) of member's businesses?
 
Originally posted by vatiger1:
I can understand the skepticism and that is one of the reasons it took me a while to join NewSpring and become an active owner. I was a huge skeptic of these mega churches as a result of all the Pastors you would hear about on TV News in the 80/90's and how corrupt they were at stealing your money. However, I joined in 2006 and really started to like it and learning more and more about the word of God.

First and foremost, the Church has the best program I have ever witnessed for children, it's called KidSpring. I have a 4 yr old daughter and 6 yr old son. They can't wait to go to Church on Sunday's because the Church has made it fun to learn about Jesus and the word of God. I can't say the same thing for me growing up in an Episcopal church as a child. It was boring as paint back then(70's, early 80's) and I despised going.

If people attending NewSpring go to see Perry Noble alone as an Worship idol, they must leave disappointed half the time. There are several other Pastors who regularly speak at NewSpring now and are very good. One of my favorites is Clayton King out of the Charlotte area. My point is NewSpring isn't about Perry Noble, he's not even there every Sunday and likely preaches about 2/3 of the Services now if I had to guess.

One of the ways, myself in particular have expanded my learnings about Christ and the teachings within the Bible is what is called "Home Groups" concept now (basically Adult Sunday School concept). It has certainly expanded my limited ceiling and understanding of what I learn on top of the Sunday services.

Sorry for the long post TigerGal, just wanted to throw my .02c in the ring. NewSpring isn't for everyone, but I believe in what they are doing and see it every Sunday. They put a TON of money back in the community throughout this State alone.



Originally posted by tiger-gal2:
Fair enough Mac Tiger. I understand your point and basically agree with it. I think you and a previous poster hit the nail on the head when you talked about immature followers and there being a low ceiling of growth there at New Spring scripturally speaking. For the lives reached there I am glad and trust that good things are happening. I have just seen too many mega star preachers brought down by their ego, love of money and power or other vices. Maybe thats the source of my skepticism, especially if you read some of Perry's critics experiences
Good post. My wife and I host a home group and have seen amazing things happen in the lives of some of our closest friends. It has been a great thing and one that we'll always do from now on. We are actually doing our own bible studies until another NewSpring-led series begins in the fall (which will be based on Perry's new book Overwhelmed fwiw).
 
Originally posted by Mr. Clemson:
Originally posted by vatiger1:
I can understand the skepticism and that is one of the reasons it took me a while to join NewSpring and become an active owner. I was a huge skeptic of these mega churches as a result of all the Pastors you would hear about on TV News in the 80/90's and how corrupt they were at stealing your money. However, I joined in 2006 and really started to like it and learning more and more about the word of God.

First and foremost, the Church has the best program I have ever witnessed for children, it's called KidSpring. I have a 4 yr old daughter and 6 yr old son. They can't wait to go to Church on Sunday's because the Church has made it fun to learn about Jesus and the word of God. I can't say the same thing for me growing up in an Episcopal church as a child. It was boring as paint back then(70's, early 80's) and I despised going.

If people attending NewSpring go to see Perry Noble alone as an Worship idol, they must leave disappointed half the time. There are several other Pastors who regularly speak at NewSpring now and are very good. One of my favorites is Clayton King out of the Charlotte area. My point is NewSpring isn't about Perry Noble, he's not even there every Sunday and likely preaches about 2/3 of the Services now if I had to guess.

One of the ways, myself in particular have expanded my learnings about Christ and the teachings within the Bible is what is called "Home Groups" concept now (basically Adult Sunday School concept). It has certainly expanded my limited ceiling and understanding of what I learn on top of the Sunday services.

Sorry for the long post TigerGal, just wanted to throw my .02c in the ring. NewSpring isn't for everyone, but I believe in what they are doing and see it every Sunday. They put a TON of money back in the community throughout this State alone.



Originally posted by tiger-gal2:
Fair enough Mac Tiger. I understand your point and basically agree with it. I think you and a previous poster hit the nail on the head when you talked about immature followers and there being a low ceiling of growth there at New Spring scripturally speaking. For the lives reached there I am glad and trust that good things are happening. I have just seen too many mega star preachers brought down by their ego, love of money and power or other vices. Maybe thats the source of my skepticism, especially if you read some of Perry's critics experiences
Good post. My wife and I host a home group and have seen amazing things happen in the lives of some of our closest friends. It has been a great thing and one that we'll always do from now on. We are actually doing our own bible studies until another NewSpring-led series begins in the fall (which will be based on Perry's new book Overwhelmed fwiw).
I'd like to read some of these. Got a link or can you tell me how to find them without having to weed through google?
 
Originally posted by Lot4tiger:

Originally posted by SWUtigers:


Also, what is it about this "church" that makes people get so defensive? I have close friends that work and/or attend services and they are borderline militant about this place.
Having witnessed PN's teachings a couple of times, that behavior is born and fostered by the way he speaks about his skeptics/critics in his sermons. His tone and attitude is one of butthurt and mockery when anyone challenges why he/New Spring do things the way they do. Reference this uncensored version of him doing just that here. While I do believe his core intentions are good, there's no denying his clear narcissism and narrow focus on numbers.
He's quite the Godly man, isn't he?
 
Originally posted by chapintiger:


Originally posted by Mr. Clemson:

Originally posted by vatiger1:
I can understand the skepticism and that is one of the reasons it took me a while to join NewSpring and become an active owner. I was a huge skeptic of these mega churches as a result of all the Pastors you would hear about on TV News in the 80/90's and how corrupt they were at stealing your money. However, I joined in 2006 and really started to like it and learning more and more about the word of God.

First and foremost, the Church has the best program I have ever witnessed for children, it's called KidSpring. I have a 4 yr old daughter and 6 yr old son. They can't wait to go to Church on Sunday's because the Church has made it fun to learn about Jesus and the word of God. I can't say the same thing for me growing up in an Episcopal church as a child. It was boring as paint back then(70's, early 80's) and I despised going.

If people attending NewSpring go to see Perry Noble alone as an Worship idol, they must leave disappointed half the time. There are several other Pastors who regularly speak at NewSpring now and are very good. One of my favorites is Clayton King out of the Charlotte area. My point is NewSpring isn't about Perry Noble, he's not even there every Sunday and likely preaches about 2/3 of the Services now if I had to guess.

One of the ways, myself in particular have expanded my learnings about Christ and the teachings within the Bible is what is called "Home Groups" concept now (basically Adult Sunday School concept). It has certainly expanded my limited ceiling and understanding of what I learn on top of the Sunday services.

Sorry for the long post TigerGal, just wanted to throw my .02c in the ring. NewSpring isn't for everyone, but I believe in what they are doing and see it every Sunday. They put a TON of money back in the community throughout this State alone.




Originally posted by tiger-gal2:
Fair enough Mac Tiger. I understand your point and basically agree with it. I think you and a previous poster hit the nail on the head when you talked about immature followers and there being a low ceiling of growth there at New Spring scripturally speaking. For the lives reached there I am glad and trust that good things are happening. I have just seen too many mega star preachers brought down by their ego, love of money and power or other vices. Maybe thats the source of my skepticism, especially if you read some of Perry's critics experiences
Good post. My wife and I host a home group and have seen amazing things happen in the lives of some of our closest friends. It has been a great thing and one that we'll always do from now on. We are actually doing our own bible studies until another NewSpring-led series begins in the fall (which will be based on Perry's new book Overwhelmed fwiw).
I'd like to read some of these. Got a link or can you tell me how to find them without having to weed through google?
Our group NewSpring developed studies are physical booklets that we picked up at the beginning of each home group series. I can mail you a few if you'd like..? The ones that we are doing independently between NewSpring-developed materials are located at the link below. We are doing the six week ones (our group meets every other Sunday evening).

Engage Bible Studies
 
Originally posted by longcreektiger:
Just curious for the newspringers... does NS encourage its members to do business with other members? Say someone is looking for a financial adviser, does NS do any promoting (direct or indirect) of member's businesses?
Nope. Naturally, you will make more connections within the church and, therefore, perhaps reach out to other church members, but NewSpring does not encourage members to do business with other members.
 
Just did a quick search of their financials and found that roughly 80% of their $50 MILLION dollar income goes to the church and it's operation. A mere 9% actually goes to mission trips. Someone correct me if I'm wrong but where is this church giving back? What are they doing SPECIFICALLY to better the community they are in? If you can provide me with specific examples with dollar figures (if possible), I would appreciate it. Personally, this would be extremely worrisome to see this graphic.

Source: NewSpring Annual Report 2013

TOTAL INCOME$50,785,156
Operating36%Staffing31%Campus Launches/Upgrades24%Missions 9%

This post was edited on 4/16 5:24 PM by SWUtigers
 
Originally posted by SWUtigers:
Just did a quick search of their financials and found that roughly 80% of their $50 MILLION dollar income goes to the church and it's operation. A mere 9% actually goes to mission trips. Someone correct me if I'm wrong but where is this church giving back? What are they doing SPECIFICALLY to better the community they are in? If you can provide me with specific examples with dollar figures (if possible), I would appreciate it. Personally, this would be extremely worrisome to see this graphic.
What are we doing to "better the community" we are in? 11,983 total salvations in 2013. That's a start.

I'm not going into any other specifics with you, because you obviously have some form of agenda against our church.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT