ADVERTISEMENT

Left Wing Academics Send Open Letter to Joe Biden Urging Him to Ignore Supreme Court Rulings the Left Doesn’t Like

TigerGrowls

Woodrush
Gold Member
Dec 21, 2001
20,825
12,103
113
This absolutely figures and is consistent with previous behavior.


By Mike LaChance Jul. 25, 2023 8:45 pm
Screen-Shot-2022-08-05-at-12.57.11-AM.jpg

Two left wing professors, one of law and another of political science, have written an open letter to Joe Biden urging him to ignore Supreme Court rulings that the left doesn’t like.
Imagine the reaction of these same professors if Trump defied the Supreme Court. That would be an assault on democracy, but it’s totally different when they do it, you see.
Is this how our cherished norms get restored? By defying the highest court in the land?

An Open Letter to the Biden Administration on Popular Constitutionalism
Aaron Belkin and I have written the following open letter to the Biden administration urging that it endorse and take steps to implement popular constitutionalism as a response to what the President has described as “not a normal” Supreme Court. We urge readers to let the administration know in their own ways that reinvigorating the long and honored tradition of popular constitutionalism is both viable and urgently needed in today’s circumstances.
We urge President Biden to restrain MAGA justices immediately by announcing that if and when they issue rulings that are based on gravely mistaken interpretations of the Constitution that undermine our most fundamental commitments, the Administration will be guided by its own constitutional interpretations.
We have worked diligently over the past five years to advocate Supreme Court expansion as a necessary strategy for restoring democracy. Although we continue to support expansion, the threat that MAGA justices pose is so extreme that reforms that do not require Congressional approval are needed at this time, and advocates and experts should encourage President Biden to take immediate action to limit the damage.
The central tenet of the solution that we recommend—Popular Constitutionalism—is that courts do not exercise exclusive authority over constitutional meaning. In practice, a President who disagrees with a court’s interpretation of the Constitution should offer and then follow an alternative interpretation. If voters disagree with the President’s interpretation, they can express their views at the ballot box.
Professor Jonathan Turley reacted at The Hill:
Tyranny of the minority: Liberal law profs urge Biden to defy the courts and the public
“I shall resist any illegal federal court order.”
When “the Court’s interpretation of the Constitution is egregiously wrong,” the president should refuse to follow it.
Those two statements were made roughly 60 years apart. The first is from segregationist Alabama Gov. George Wallace (D). The second was made by two liberal professors this month.
In one of the most chilling developments in our history, the left has come to embrace the authoritarian language and logic of segregationists in calling for defiance and radical measures against the Supreme Court…
What is most striking about these professors is how they continue to claim they are defenders of democracy, yet seek to use unilateral executive authority to defy the courts and, in cases like the tuition forgiveness and affirmative action, the majority of the public.
This is precisely why AOC and other Democrats have been calling the Supreme Court illegitimate for months.
There are no coincidences.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: DW4_2016
This absolutely figures and is consistent with previous behavior.


By Mike LaChance Jul. 25, 2023 8:45 pm
Screen-Shot-2022-08-05-at-12.57.11-AM.jpg

Two left wing professors, one of law and another of political science, have written an open letter to Joe Biden urging him to ignore Supreme Court rulings that the left doesn’t like.
Imagine the reaction of these same professors if Trump defied the Supreme Court. That would be an assault on democracy, but it’s totally different when they do it, you see.
Is this how our cherished norms get restored? By defying the highest court in the land?


Professor Jonathan Turley reacted at The Hill:

This is precisely why AOC and other Democrats have been calling the Supreme Court illegitimate for months.
There are no coincidences.
You work so hard to be offended.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dpic73
 
This absolutely figures and is consistent with previous behavior.


By Mike LaChance Jul. 25, 2023 8:45 pm
Screen-Shot-2022-08-05-at-12.57.11-AM.jpg

Two left wing professors, one of law and another of political science, have written an open letter to Joe Biden urging him to ignore Supreme Court rulings that the left doesn’t like.
Imagine the reaction of these same professors if Trump defied the Supreme Court. That would be an assault on democracy, but it’s totally different when they do it, you see.
Is this how our cherished norms get restored? By defying the highest court in the land?


Professor Jonathan Turley reacted at The Hill:

This is precisely why AOC and other Democrats have been calling the Supreme Court illegitimate for months.
There are no coincidences.
Neither side should be ignoring the supreme court
 
Wow... TGP must be in trouble with the writer's strike or something. You'd THINK they'd be able to make up something better than THIS. So two random dudes that teach at some college, wrote a letter to the President telling him to do something that TGP doesn't like.

That's all for today? I'm offended that I can't even be offended. Of course people should obey the Supreme Court's Rulings. Where has Biden ever said he wouldn't?

I mean if the Supreme Court said to redraw voting districts in a liberal state, shouldn't they do it? And if a liberal state had some sort of barrier to keep people out and the Supreme Court said to take that down, shouldn't they do it?

Methinks TGP is making stuff up to be offended about when the REAL THING is happening now... only it's conservative states not obeying.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT