First, I want to applaud you
@GilaMonsta, plus
@KennyRogersRoasters and
@Tigerdad56, for your attempts at civil, intelligent discussion of these matters. There have been others, to be sure, but sadly the intelligent comments are buried by the folks that think "he who yells the loudest, wins" that rules any internet forum.
I'm responding because this topic (due to my familial ties to Law Enforcement) interests/bothers me greatly. There are some rather sad facts that have been overlooked in nearly every post here and every 'news' story on this topic, because they don't "fit the template". The first is the
fact (based on statistical data from 2012 through 2015) that as a black man, you're 40 times more likely to be killed by another black person (civilian, not law enforcement) than you are to be killed by a white police officer. This is data compiled by the CDC and FBI.
If the averages (and if my math is correct, and I'm pretty sure it is) over that span continue, that means that 86 black men (between the ages of 18 and 34) will die a violent death in the U.S.
this week. Of those 86, 80 (93%) will be killed by another black civilian, not a law enforcement officer. Two to three will be killed by a police officer (the number is 2.58); how many of those are criminal vs. justifiable (truly in defense of themselves or the public) I have no idea...the data/analysis varies too wildly from source-to-source to draw conclusions.
I get that what we've seen in the last two weeks is damning to police officers, and, barring any exculpatory evidence that may surface, the officers in those videos should pay a severe penalty (as in whatever the max sentence for manslaughter/murder is their state, with zero chance for parole). After all, as officers of the law, they should serve a higher calling. My friends/family in law enforcement will tell you the same. One unnecessary death at the hands of law enforcement is one too many.
But all of this evidence begs the question, who's the bigger threat to black men? I know the answer is obvious to all of us, but in all of the "face time" afforded to BLM folks in the last 10 days, I'm yet to see this as a part of the conversation. Why? Is it that the media outlets are more interested is stirring controversy than actually reporting the facts? (I'd likely buy this explanation, BTW).
And, to be fair, I know this is being discussed in
some chapters of the movement, because I saw a photo of a young black man at a rally/march wearing a t-shirt that read "Black Lives Matter, so let's stop killing each other". Why is it not at the forefront of every statement from a BLM member?
To be clear, I'm not trying to paint you (or BLM) into the proverbial corner, or pick anything that even resembles a fight. As I said, I have friends and family members in law enforcement, plus an innate respect of all human life, so this entire atmosphere of unrest concerns me, but I'm not so myopic as to be unwilling to listen to both sides. The questions I raise are out of a genuine desire to understand both sides of the equation.